While catching up on my LM_Net reading this morning, I was absolutely appalled to view the video that inspired the thread "This is a Librarian's Nightmare."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gJCdIx_n0U
(This video is no longer available.)
I've now learned that School Library Journal printed an article on it on October 19th.
John Ericsson Middle School 126 had been sharing space with some charter schools, while the LMS had exerted years of effort to remodel their library, and now it is being converted to a teacher's lounge for the charter school teachers, according to the video. The details seem to be glossed over in the journal article, saying only that the library had been taken over by the charter school.
I find the idea sickening, upsetting, and depressing. Never mind all the hard work, volunteer labor, and donations that went in to the remodel of the library. The students' library should never be taken away unless there is a flood or fire. I think the school's principal is deluded about the quality of library education her students will receive with a mobile librarian. I just can't believe it.
Monday, October 26, 2009
Sunday, October 25, 2009
Expert Thinking
Okay, I'm not going to complain about Doug Johnson's post this time. The Blue Skunk Blog asked "What defines 'expert thinking?'" on October 12th. It encourages librarians and teachers to think outside the box. I especially liked the example of Freida, who is a good reader and needs to check out more than three books a week. Before, I might have said that the same rules apply to Freida that apply to everyone else, but his concept of "expert thinking" is changing my mind. Since we're supposed to be professionals, we should be problems solvers rather than clerks. I love that he pointed out that this could be solved in more than one way, for those of us who are too rule-bound for our own good, though. I want to be known as a problem solver, not an automaton.
Doug's 13 point checklist
Doug Johnson posted an exahustive list yesterday, October 24th, called "13 Point Library Media Program Checklist for School Principals, 2009," and at first I wanted to know who would be reading it besides LMS's. Then I found that he offered it to his readers to use as they will.
I don't think I could present the whole checklist to an administrator. Even if I were bringing my professional practices up to snuff, it is a daunting thought. From clerical and technical support, to facilities, curriculum, and long-term planning, it could almost be called diagnostic tool for the issues of the entire school. On the other hand, if an LMS wanted to target a certain area, portions of the checklist could be used to advocate for hiring a paraprofessional for clerical tasks or increasing the library's budget.
However, if an administrator got ahold of this independently, it might make for broad changes for the library media center that would be positive for the learning community.
I don't think I could present the whole checklist to an administrator. Even if I were bringing my professional practices up to snuff, it is a daunting thought. From clerical and technical support, to facilities, curriculum, and long-term planning, it could almost be called diagnostic tool for the issues of the entire school. On the other hand, if an LMS wanted to target a certain area, portions of the checklist could be used to advocate for hiring a paraprofessional for clerical tasks or increasing the library's budget.
However, if an administrator got ahold of this independently, it might make for broad changes for the library media center that would be positive for the learning community.
Doug Johnson on teachers and cyberbullying
I had to check out ratemyteachers.com for this. Fortunately, neither I nor my previous employers were entered on this site. I don't think teachers should be reading their ratings on these websites as a general rule, though. However, Doug's Oct. 25 post had me thinking in another direction before I realized that he was specifically talking about Internet sites for rating teachers.
I think if a teacher does not take the necessary steps to make their Facebook or other pages secure with the appropriate security settings, they could be harrassed, if we don't want to call it cyberbullying; I could envision a student making a bogus profile and then harrassing a teacher with foul, lewd remarks. If it can happen to a student on a social networking site, it can happen to anyone. Additionally, I think teachers have to be very careful about who they allow as friends on social networking sites. I have seen that some of my former colleagues are friends with some current students on Facebook. I'm not convinced that it's a good idea, especially if the student is still a minor and in school. Do we really want to read each other's rant about what happened in class today?
I think if a teacher does not take the necessary steps to make their Facebook or other pages secure with the appropriate security settings, they could be harrassed, if we don't want to call it cyberbullying; I could envision a student making a bogus profile and then harrassing a teacher with foul, lewd remarks. If it can happen to a student on a social networking site, it can happen to anyone. Additionally, I think teachers have to be very careful about who they allow as friends on social networking sites. I have seen that some of my former colleagues are friends with some current students on Facebook. I'm not convinced that it's a good idea, especially if the student is still a minor and in school. Do we really want to read each other's rant about what happened in class today?
High school independent reading
Nancy Carlson's LM_Net post on Oct. 15th regarding pushing adult books on HS students rather than great YA books set me to thinking. The English teachers in her school are bringing students to select books for "free" reading, but they are also apparently editorializing on students' choices. She's glad they're promoting independent reading but disappointed that they can't lay aside their teacher hat for a moment, I think.
Now, if I were an English teacher giving an assignment for a book report/talk/review, I would feel justified in setting guidelines. However, under the context of independent reading, I would prefer to engage students about the book if I'd read it or ask about it if I hadn't. I think Nancy's justified to promote reading for the sake of reading.
Now, if I were an English teacher giving an assignment for a book report/talk/review, I would feel justified in setting guidelines. However, under the context of independent reading, I would prefer to engage students about the book if I'd read it or ask about it if I hadn't. I think Nancy's justified to promote reading for the sake of reading.
(Gasp!) You want to throw away Tolstoy?
Jaclyn Alder/Kirt Winslow posted about a unique situation: a small library with a small fiction section. Apparently books like Moby Dick, Sister Carrie, and others are taking up valuable space that could house books the students would actually read. Do you or do you not weed them to make room for new books?
I would ask a few questions. Will students have to find it and read it independently for an English assignment? Would a freshly printed, easier to read copy have more appeal? I have heard that the new book smell makes even some of the old standbys more attractive. Which of the classics are most frequently requested and loved by readers in my school?
I am not in favor of sweeping them all out the door because they are old, but I think a school library has to consider their patrons, their collection, and their budget when making a decision like this.
I would ask a few questions. Will students have to find it and read it independently for an English assignment? Would a freshly printed, easier to read copy have more appeal? I have heard that the new book smell makes even some of the old standbys more attractive. Which of the classics are most frequently requested and loved by readers in my school?
I am not in favor of sweeping them all out the door because they are old, but I think a school library has to consider their patrons, their collection, and their budget when making a decision like this.
Holding books for readers
I really like the hit that Patti Stein posted on Oct. 12 about various librarians' methods of managing books on hold. Having had some students request a book and then not want it when it comes back is a problem I've seen first hand. My favorite recommendations on her "hit list" were the ones that suggested taking the reserved books to the student's classroom or comm. arts class, but now, as I'm writing this, I wonder if that is a breach of privacy. More than one LMS suggested it, though. Perhaps Donna Van Cleve's book hold sign is more appropriate.
I'm starting to get the idea, though, that we shouldn't take it personally if a student requests a book but changes his or her mind when the book is available. We're there to serve, right?
I'm starting to get the idea, though, that we shouldn't take it personally if a student requests a book but changes his or her mind when the book is available. We're there to serve, right?
Sunday, October 11, 2009
Manga/Graphic novels
Not having had graphic novels or Manga (proper noun?) in my first library, I didn't have to think about this topic. However, the viewpoints collected and shared by Vicki Nelson on LM_Net on Oct. 9th about reclassifying and relocating the materials are certainly current concerns for many library media specialists. I find it interesting that she differentiates between Manga and her other graphic novels and shelves them separates them. Lisa Von Drasek, however, puts fictional graphic novels in with fiction, Shakespeare in nonfiction, etc. Jeffrey Hastings is thinking of developing new call numbers for them. I wonder what purists would say? Would they go with Von Drasek? I hear a lot of librarians say to put books where students are most likely to find them.
Pesky grad students
Ah, we love to overgeneralize and share our "discoveries" with the world long before we've developed a sufficient vocabulary for discussing it with our more experienced colleagues. Alicia Brosen, of Queens, NY, posted about lii.org being better than Wikipedia on LM_Net on Oct. 6th, and her "misconceptions" immediately brought on a flurry of correction from veterans. I will concede that Johan Koren, one of the responders, is more technically correct in identifying the difference between an index of web sites and a single web site. Another response discussed LII's shortcomings. I can't blame Alicia for wanting to share the index with others, though. I wasn't aware of it before, and now I've at least examined it once.
I'm stretching here
In trying to find something worthwhile to blog about for this library science and information services course I'm in, I often find recently that I have to "stretch" to make it applicable to library media center administration. This post is no different. David Warlick is discussing data in his Oct. 5th post, and I feel like he and the blogger he is reading, David Wiley, are bemoaning the state of the educational system. I appreciate the fact that Warlick isn't a fan of data driven decision making, but he and Wiley seem as though they're out to discredit education professionals based on the data they gather as well. We have enough scrutiny of teachers being merely babysitters with a degree or sexual predators. Now the data collected in the classroom is suspect.
I can't even get a handle if Warlick knows whether Wiley is talking about gradebooks or standardized testing. From the sound of what he excerpts, it seems Wiley is discussing gradebooks.
Now I'm all for students becoming self-analyzers and self-assessors, whether or not technology is involved, but I believe we're a long way from all content being digital and analyzed digitally. It rings of science fiction in all but the richest school districts.
I can't even get a handle if Warlick knows whether Wiley is talking about gradebooks or standardized testing. From the sound of what he excerpts, it seems Wiley is discussing gradebooks.
Now I'm all for students becoming self-analyzers and self-assessors, whether or not technology is involved, but I believe we're a long way from all content being digital and analyzed digitally. It rings of science fiction in all but the richest school districts.
The other side of the 2.0 divide
On Oct. 7, Doug Johnson blog entry "Where are the others?" asked an important question as illustrated in the title, after attending a presentation about media specialists and social media. Actually, he is sharing the perspective of a response by a library media specialist named Beth. While she is cognizant of those in the profession who do not like change, she is more concerned with the harried LMS's who struggle to maintain Internet access and have no consistent paraprofessional support in their libraries. She wants to hear from them, too, to learn about the professional barriers they face. I guess she feels that sometimes the deck is stacked against them in the Web 2.0 world.
Johnson poses some interesting thoughts after sharing Beth's ideas. He asks, "Do we owe an apology to those who struggle in silence? How can we give a voice to those who choose not to network?" While I find most of his stuff at least an interesting read, even younger teacher librarians working in a library with almost no preparation in the field may find themselves in the same situations as Beth describes. My first year as a half-time librarian was not the time I was thinking about social networking sites or professional listservs. I was trying to keep my head above water in a bad situation. Doug, could you give us a small break here? We're not all dentists trained in 1975; in fact, a number of us weren't even born yet.
Johnson poses some interesting thoughts after sharing Beth's ideas. He asks, "Do we owe an apology to those who struggle in silence? How can we give a voice to those who choose not to network?" While I find most of his stuff at least an interesting read, even younger teacher librarians working in a library with almost no preparation in the field may find themselves in the same situations as Beth describes. My first year as a half-time librarian was not the time I was thinking about social networking sites or professional listservs. I was trying to keep my head above water in a bad situation. Doug, could you give us a small break here? We're not all dentists trained in 1975; in fact, a number of us weren't even born yet.
Monday, October 5, 2009
"Playing" the Game
David Warlick has recently been focusing on the generation gap and how "youngsters" do things differently, most specifically on Sept. 28, the fact that they don't read the instruction manual when playing a new video game. However, he confesses to doing the same thing with the new software he encounters professionally; he likes to play around with it.
His point is can teachers demand instructions from students who work this way. Well, I don't think it's just the teachers asking for instructions. In fact, Missouri state GLE's frequently reference following directions in a sequential manner, and many speech classes require students to do at least one demonstration speech involving sequential instructions. I think we as students and educators have to be able to do both.
His point is can teachers demand instructions from students who work this way. Well, I don't think it's just the teachers asking for instructions. In fact, Missouri state GLE's frequently reference following directions in a sequential manner, and many speech classes require students to do at least one demonstration speech involving sequential instructions. I think we as students and educators have to be able to do both.
Teachers with assignment burnout
Kristin Fontichiaro is actually asking for input from librarians on a scenario she poses about a teacher sick of a War Report that he's done year after year in her Oct. 1st post with School Library Monthly. In her description, I can just feel that teacher's ulcer developing at the thought of another round of the same old reports, and we all know the candy will do nothing for him.
What about multimedia or primary sources? I know in Missouri, we've had some changes with MOREnet, but I found while doing some exploration for a screencast assignment that Searchasaurus has primary historical resources. Surely there are databases or quality web sites out there a librarian could recommend, whether or not she'd know which one to recommend immediately or if she'd have to research or rely on LM_Net wisdom to find them. Not only that, although we are losing WWII veterans, there is also the possibility of having students interview veterans for first person accounts.
This really shows that the LMS must be a resourceful person indeed.
What about multimedia or primary sources? I know in Missouri, we've had some changes with MOREnet, but I found while doing some exploration for a screencast assignment that Searchasaurus has primary historical resources. Surely there are databases or quality web sites out there a librarian could recommend, whether or not she'd know which one to recommend immediately or if she'd have to research or rely on LM_Net wisdom to find them. Not only that, although we are losing WWII veterans, there is also the possibility of having students interview veterans for first person accounts.
This really shows that the LMS must be a resourceful person indeed.
Teachers in the elementary library
Janet Perry offered some pros and cons on having elementary teachers in the library on Sept. 29. She doesn't like it if they move to discipline when her lesson is in progress. However, she has no qualms addressing that issue. I really liked that she trains them to run the computer; as the sole adult in a library, it's really difficult to assist students and deal with circulation.
I think a lot of teachers who've been used to having the library as another "special" would balk at the idea of changing the system. Is it possible to get staff and administrative support for bringing the teacher into the library along with the students? I'll guess it depends on the school itself.
I think a lot of teachers who've been used to having the library as another "special" would balk at the idea of changing the system. Is it possible to get staff and administrative support for bringing the teacher into the library along with the students? I'll guess it depends on the school itself.
Booking Library Time
Lisa Gonzalez asked into setting limits on library usage on Sept. 28th. She has a department of her school that's had it for 3 weeks and wants to book for 2 more. They're keeping other groups out of the library, and Lisa has worked really hard to get the school invested in the library.
She doesn't discuss how long she's been in the position directly, but I'm guessing it is her second year if no one last year wanted to use the library. I think she needs to grow a little backbone. Certainly, the online assessment program is important to the individual department, but she may need to elist the support of her administrator to make that department see that the library is important to others as well. I don't think I would think twice about limiting a department that's hogged the library every day for the first month of school.
She doesn't discuss how long she's been in the position directly, but I'm guessing it is her second year if no one last year wanted to use the library. I think she needs to grow a little backbone. Certainly, the online assessment program is important to the individual department, but she may need to elist the support of her administrator to make that department see that the library is important to others as well. I don't think I would think twice about limiting a department that's hogged the library every day for the first month of school.
Thursday, October 1, 2009
The Occasional Necessity of Censorship
Janet Perry posted on Sept. 25 in regards to a censorship discussion going on on LM_Net. Having worked in a K-12 library myself, I have to agree that there must be some lines drawn regarding what younger students may check out. I wouldn't say I always did a great job of drawing that line, but it is interesting that Janet splits her collection by the age of the protagonist: 5-13 goes on the elementary side and 14 and up goes on the high school side. Let's face it; we don't really need a precocious 4th grader checking out The Color Purple. Whether I would censor Twilight from middle school students is another matter; it's what all the 7th and 8th graders I taught were reading in the last two years, and I don't personally find it offensive, although it might be more emotionally mature than some of them should read. Of course, these same students could also go to the public library and check out much more "offensive" or "obscene" books there if they have their own library card.
Pulling Her Hair Out!!
Martha Morgan's Sept. 18th post to LM_Net set off a firestorm of responses, only a few of which I will trouble my readers with. In a nutshell, she's moved to a different school in her district, along with about 200 students. She has only volunteer help and has no time for lunch or a planning period. It appears her administrators are railroading her to run the library as her predecessor did, but with an addition of 200 students and 10 classes to accommodate. Harry F. Coffill replied, questioning her about union representation and what her contract stipulates, while Guusje Moore responded to his remark that not all states' teachers unions have pull, and some of us have to put up with our contractual obligations or look for another job. I personally identify with Carol Hager's envy of librarians who get to do Web 2.0 stuff and collaborate with teachers; I didn't have much opportunity for that in my last position, either.
Doug Johnson on Guides
On 9/27, Doug Johnson posted a poignant reflection about guides. Growing out of a hiking trip to the Grand Canyon, he points to several things that we as teachers and librarians should do. They include pushing others to do new things, modeling new things, showing things that might be missed, demonstrating our own proficiency, and smoothing the way for those we work with. I hope I could live up to those goals in my professional life in and out of the library.
American Students for School Reform??
Kristin Fontichiaro posted on the AASL blog relating to a New York Times article which covered students in South Africa for better schools. I'm afraid I have to echo Kristin's comment: "Yet I wonder how many of our students would march so they could learn more." There are some students you know who don't feel the class is meeting their needs, but by and large, I fear that apathy is widespread. Many of our students aren't taking advantage of the opportunities they have, and our culture is obsessed with the pursuit of pleasure and doesn't always demonstrate an understanding of delayed gratification.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)