Sunday, October 11, 2009
Pesky grad students
Ah, we love to overgeneralize and share our "discoveries" with the world long before we've developed a sufficient vocabulary for discussing it with our more experienced colleagues. Alicia Brosen, of Queens, NY, posted about lii.org being better than Wikipedia on LM_Net on Oct. 6th, and her "misconceptions" immediately brought on a flurry of correction from veterans. I will concede that Johan Koren, one of the responders, is more technically correct in identifying the difference between an index of web sites and a single web site. Another response discussed LII's shortcomings. I can't blame Alicia for wanting to share the index with others, though. I wasn't aware of it before, and now I've at least examined it once.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
What was the excitement about? That Wikipedia is a "single" source while lii.org is a listing of a variety of sites?
ReplyDelete